THE LATEST
« »

Monday, October 16, 2006

Torture and the 'Ticking Timebomb'

Sean Gonsalves shows that even the 'ticking timebomb scenario' is a lousy argument for torture.

Working for Change:

Historian Alfred McCoy shows how the ticking-bomb scenario involves the coming together of several unlikely occurrences:

1.) The interrogators somehow have enough detailed foreknowledge of the plot to know they must interrogate this very person and do it right now;

2.) Authorities, for some unexplained reason, are missing just a few critical details that only this captive can divulge;

3.) With just one chance to get the information that only this captive can divulge, torture increases the chances of cooperation.


In other words, it's never going to happen outside a James Bond movie. There's a lot more to the article, but that just jumped out at me. Go check it out.

Tags:

Search Archive:

Custom Search